tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post50205776763178347..comments2024-03-27T12:58:00.592-07:00Comments on Snowbrush: What is it that I DO believe?.Snowbrushhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/00436087215476479042noreply@blogger.comBlogger15125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-24345043849493568942015-03-08T10:57:36.957-07:002015-03-08T10:57:36.957-07:00I didn't feel your reply was disrespectful. T...I didn't feel your reply was disrespectful. The first time I checked back in to see your response I actually missed seeing it as I scanned down through your replies.Sparkling Redhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12799366562472325812noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-88100755028687921572015-03-06T08:00:27.313-08:002015-03-06T08:00:27.313-08:00“So extrapolated empathy?”
Yes, I see your point....“So extrapolated empathy?”<br /><br />Yes, I see your point. I really do. Thank you.<br /><br />“I get much more from reading a good novel”<br /><br />I think you err in framing it as an either/or? I write as I do, but I also read many novels.<br /><br />“I was married to a man who spent countless hours navel-gazing”<br /><br />The word for this is omphaloskepsis.<br /><br />“Now I prefer to dig in the Good Earth and read great stories by first-rate writers.”<br /><br />I love to dig, but I don’t mean in a garden, I mean deep holes. I love the work, I love the odors, and I love seeing what’s down there—the shades of clay, the kinds of rocks, and an occasional fossil along with the leavings of all the people who have passed this way. I also love dirt. When I have a neighbor who has some topsoil to get rid of, I go get it and either scatter it about the yard or store it for when I need it. My wife says I’m a collector of dirt. Then in winter, I rescue earth worms that come up to escape the rain and end up on the bike path where they get run over. As for “first-rate writers,” I almost invariably read the works of people who wrote at least 80-years ago because a writer can be considered first-rate in his or her time and be completely forgotten a few decades later. By reading the old authors, I know I really am getting the best.<br /><br />Perhaps, the trouble with your husband was that he was too one-sided, but then if he were to talk about you, I’m sure he could come with some problems that you had.Snowbrushhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00436087215476479042noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-25195918322430087992015-03-06T00:27:39.965-08:002015-03-06T00:27:39.965-08:00I get much more from reading a good novel than tal...I get much more from reading a good novel than talking about some mystical being or pure ideas. (I'm currently enjoying All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr. Who could need anything else?) For a painful 12 years in my early life, I was married to a man who spent countless hours navel-gazing and pondering all the great mysteries of life. In the end I decided he was a bore. And I think that marriage turned me off all forms of philosophy - which I had actually loved in college. Now I prefer to dig in the Good Earth and read great stories by first-rate writers.Chartreusehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05919069110736697400noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-35237196618028864312015-03-05T12:37:04.736-08:002015-03-05T12:37:04.736-08:00I would put my aching heart on the empathy side of...I would put my aching heart on the empathy side of the equation. I don't share your feelinga about God, but have gone through stages of seeking answers to questions which were important to me, where no answers that I could accept could be found. So extrapolated empathy?<br />I don't understand your search, but it doesn't bore me at all. Confuses me some days, but no boredom is involved.Elephant's Childhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06650565833097914052noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-3097264220810861452015-03-05T12:25:48.507-08:002015-03-05T12:25:48.507-08:00Empathy is good, but pity is a drag, and when you ...Empathy is good, but pity is a drag, and when you say your heart aches, I don’t really know which it is. As I see it, pity separates people, and it unintentionally leads the pitier to either feel lucky or superior. Still, it’s unavoidable at times, like when someone’s whole family is wiped out in a car wreck. As for me, though, I’m overall happy with my life, so I don’t feel that pity applies to me. As for empathy, I love to receive that, but isn’t it hard for you given that you don’t share my feelings about God? I think of how hard it would be for me to emphasize, for example, with someone whose wife died because I’ve never suffered anywhere near such a loss as that, so I couldn’t relate it to my own experience. <br /><br />When I write about religion, I think that I often: bore people; or they feel sorry for me; or they make the judgment that I should have long ago put such thoughts out of my life, and there’s something wrong with me that I haven’t; or they think I’m looking for advice. What I really want is understanding and to feel that I’m stimulating people by telling them interesting things that they don’t already know. I’m always learning, always trying to go deeper into the subject and deeper into myself, but I think that this post, especially, won’t even be read thoroughly by most people. One reason for this is that some of my atheist readers think that anything connected with religion is bullshit. For example, I have a friend who said he wasn’t interested in religion because it’s nothing but a lie and has nothing to teach him. This put a distance between us because it amounted to pronouncing a major interest of mine as being off-limits for discussion. I think it’s also an intellectual mistake to make such a black-and-white judgment. No one would be so dense as to say such a thing about fiction, poetry, or art, but they say it about religion because all they see in it is stupid people doing stupid things when the truth is that it’s a nuanced subject. Besides, this post isn’t about religion so much as it is about me.Snowbrushhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00436087215476479042noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-88454988306480938742015-03-05T11:01:13.589-08:002015-03-05T11:01:13.589-08:00Empathy is part of who I am, just as questionning ...Empathy is part of who I am, just as questionning is part of who you are. I get pain from my empathy, but I also get benefits. Just as you do from your questions.Elephant's Childhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06650565833097914052noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-37262919367042363762015-03-05T09:47:49.498-08:002015-03-05T09:47:49.498-08:00Maybe I’m wrong, but I wonder if anyone is really ...Maybe I’m wrong, but I wonder if anyone is really reading this post. I just went back over it and shortened it some, but I couldn’t take much out. I thought of making it into two posts, but I obviously didn’t.<br /><br />“When a parent brings a very young child to the dentist, the child suffers and screams at the parent: "You're mean! I hate you! You make bad things happen to me!" But in the long run, the parent is acting in the child's best interest.”<br /><br />Red, I hope you didn’t take my comment to your comment as disrespectful. There’s a word for trying to reconcile suffering with God’s goodness. It’s called theodicy. Certainly, we can fall back on the thought that we simply don’t know enough to pass judgment on God, but I would hold that we do. The parent in your example could do no better, but human parents aren’t unlimited beings. If they were, the child even need to go to the dentist.<br /><br />“I've gone through various patterns of thinking, including seeing God as the universe.”<br /><br />I tried that for ten minutes one night! I cannot for the life of me understand the attraction of calling the universe God. I also have the sneaky suspicion that those who do so imagine themselves somehow more “sensitive” than “ordinary atheists” who simply call the universe the universe. I mean, come on, pantheists are atheists too; they’re just in denial. Spinoza denied his atheism, but no one but other pantheists has ever been able to understand why he wasn’t.<br /><br />“I'll never answer those questions so I've largely given up considering them.”<br /><br />Peggy is the same way. Almost all atheists are that way.Snowbrushhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00436087215476479042noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-62872733924551941912015-03-05T08:15:53.984-08:002015-03-05T08:15:53.984-08:00I've gone through various patterns of thinking...I've gone through various patterns of thinking, including seeing God as the universe. I've also realized that I'll never answer those questions so I've largely given up considering them.Charles Gramlichhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02052592247572253641noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-90709009500496052332015-03-05T01:12:19.349-08:002015-03-05T01:12:19.349-08:00“as I get older I come closer to believing that Je...“as I get older I come closer to believing that Jesus Christ never really lived,”<br /><br />I have so little regard for what he supposedly said that it doesn’t matter to me one way or the other. His is simply the religion that I inherited.<br /><br />“In my 20s, I pursued biblical studies in depth because I wanted to obtain the "peace that surpasses all understanding" that my sister got from her biblical studies.”<br /><br />I naively thought that studying the Bible in college would provide me with the answers that I couldn’t get in church, but it just increased my doubts. Liberal churches, at least, don’t affirm that the Bible is about God but rather about its writers’ impressions of God. Some of its writers were, as you’re well aware, the ancient equivalent of the soldiers of the Islamic State. You’re also right, of course, about hell only coming to us through the supposedly gentle Jesus, but who knows what he really said, and what does it matter anyway? As I see it, the Bible is such a mess as to be almost meaningless, so I’m ever astounded that people think it’s a wonderful book filled with “family values” and, like Superman, “For peace, justice, and the American Way.”<br /><br />“I keep in mind the possibility that there is a greater good that we cannot conceive of. I know it seems like a stretch, but maybe, just maybe…”<br /><br />One might hope, but then again, it’s awfully to imagine the good in a woman giving birth to a baby with hydrocephalus, or the squirrel that got stuck behind the chain that held the house that I had made for it and starved to death, or the baby seals that are eaten by killer whales the first time they venture into the ocean, and so on. So much suffering from which nothing is learned. If there is such a being as God, that being could have surely gotten all the good with none of the bad. Such a being wouldn’t have been forced to say, that, “Well, it’s terrible that creatures suffer, but it’s for the greater good, so I have no choice but to let it happen.”<br /><br />“my heart aches when I read of your attempts to meet that need.”<br /><br />My heart aches when I read that your aches! I wouldn’t have you do it on my account. Really, I wouldn’t. It’s no good to you, and no good to me.Snowbrushhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00436087215476479042noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-58355413462233900642015-03-04T22:18:08.647-08:002015-03-04T22:18:08.647-08:00As you know, that is a need I don't share. Ju...As you know, that is a need I don't share. Just the same, my heart aches when I read of your attempts to meet that need.Elephant's Childhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06650565833097914052noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-38565741832541963542015-03-04T14:26:11.158-08:002015-03-04T14:26:11.158-08:00I can accept that ultimate reality may not be cons...I can accept that ultimate reality may not be conscious. From the evidence that I understand, that seems perhaps more likely than not.<br /><br />On the other hand, consider this metaphor. When a parent brings a very young child to the dentist, the child suffers and screams at the parent: "You're mean! I hate you! You make bad things happen to me!" But in the long run, the parent is acting in the child's best interest. I keep in mind the possibility that there is a greater good that we cannot conceive of. I know it seems like a stretch, but maybe, just maybe...Sparkling Redhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12799366562472325812noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-32604968599757249442015-03-04T14:12:14.297-08:002015-03-04T14:12:14.297-08:00In my 20s, I pursued biblical studies in depth bec...In my 20s, I pursued biblical studies in depth because I wanted to obtain the "peace that surpasses all understanding" that my sister got from her biblical studies. <br /><br />To her it brought peace. To me it brought anger that I did not understand until I dug deeper into biblical references, concordances, and maps. Then I realized I was reading fiction and decided I could not place fiction as my base of belief. <br /><br />But my true realization did not come until I made peace with the fact that most (and by most, I mean MOST) religious people have not pursued an intellectual study of the contents of the bible....to the point where most (and when I say most, I mean MOST) theists have not bothered to read the book. They place their beliefs in what they are told they believe.<br /><br />Many place their beliefs on that good old standby: feelings. "My heart knows."<br /><br />A lot of atheists attain the same good feeling when singing a cherished hymn from their youth, or participating in a learned action taught from duplicating their parents. A feeling does not recognize truth from fiction.<br /><br />If there was truly a god of the bible, he endorsed slavery and stonings. In defense mode, theists say the NT negated god's prior decisions. "Ooops. I did a boo boo". <br /><br />Yet only in the NT is the possibility of eternal damnation and hell mentioned, FURTHER increasing his atrocities under the guise of being a good ol' boy "son".<br /><br />I find more pleasure in a sunset now by appreciating how fashionably beautiful the world, the entire universe, evolved without trying to equate it with an all powerful, all loving, beast of burden and cruelty.lotta joyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12742978845913126675noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-89171874631851979402015-03-04T13:26:23.720-08:002015-03-04T13:26:23.720-08:00You bring this topic to a higher level of profundi...You bring this topic to a higher level of profundity than I am capable of appreciating, but as I get older I come closer to believing that Jesus Christ never really lived, but is a compilation of stories turned into myths and grafted as a religion onto a fading Empire. I believe in spirituality, the need to connect to something greater than myself, but religion is as Karl Marx said: the opiate of the masses. stephen Hayeshttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17659054447637207734noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-64776670543061245992015-03-04T13:04:52.007-08:002015-03-04T13:04:52.007-08:00“I just cannot write anything about something that...“I just cannot write anything about something that is a complete fantastical nonsense.”<br /><br />Theism can be false in terms of reality and still be meaningful in other ways—political, anthropological, and metaphorical, to name three.<br /><br />“came across a clever item from 'Possum' and would like to have your opinion on it”<br /><br />I found it delightful, but what is it’s point, really? It’s saying that, sometimes, a person might believe something without evidence, and later be shown to have been correct. While this is true, it doesn’t mean that some other thing that is believed without evidence is also likely to be true. <br /><br />Imagine that you, Possum, and I are stranded on a desert island, and I announce that a ship will rescue us in twelve days. When asked why I believe this, I simply say that is is a matter of faith. Sure enough, we are rescued on the 12th day, but does this mean that I have ESP or that I lucked out? The likelihood is that I lucked out. Of course, if I had said that the ship was going to be 14-years old, green and yellow, have a 43-year old captain from Bogue Chitto, Mississippi, and be carrying 1,216 people, the possibility of ESP would greatly increase. Such is the case with this story, only the detailed comparison between life after birth and life after death is imposed. In other words, there’s no connection between the one and the other, no reason to think that because one is true the other is true.<br /><br />When John Kennedy was killed, someone went to the trouble to make an approximately a 25-item list of what was intended to be uncanny comparisons between Kennedy and Abraham Lincoln, who was also assassinated. The list included facts such as that the name of Kennedy’s secretary was Lincoln, and the name of Lincoln’s secretary was Kennedy, and so on (I might be wrong about these particular names, but you get my point).The problem is that if you look hard enough for similarities between almost any two people or events, you will find them simply because there are thousands of possibilities to choose from. The person who wrote this story imposed as many similarities as possible between Christian belief and post-natal experiences, but, as with the Kennedy/LIncoln comparisons, the story doesn’t constitute evidence. It’s also possible that the two babies might have been stillborn in which case the skeptic would have won the day regarding most of the predictions.Snowbrushhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00436087215476479042noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-23830899.post-33783345904440965022015-03-04T12:08:24.941-08:002015-03-04T12:08:24.941-08:00Hi Snowy. I cannot say anything that would be of ...Hi Snowy. I cannot say anything that would be of interest or argument as I just cannot write anything about something that is a complete fantastical nonsense.<br /><br />However, I came across a clever item from 'Possum' and would like to have your opinion on it:<br />http://possumlane.blogspot.co.uk/2015/03/life-after-delivery.htmlPhilipHhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06811831703263176415noreply@blogger.com